Current:Home > InvestAppeals court lets Kentucky enforce ban on transgender care for minors-LoTradeCoin
Appeals court lets Kentucky enforce ban on transgender care for minors
View Date:2024-12-24 07:19:02
A federal appeals court is allowing Kentucky to enforce a recently enacted ban on gender-affirming care for young transgender people while the issue is being litigated.
The 2-1 decision Monday from the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati is not unexpected. The same three-judge panel ruled the same way earlier this month on a similar case in Tennessee.
The Kentucky law, enacted this year over the veto of Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear, prevents transgender minors from accessing puberty blockers and hormone therapy.
At least 20 states have now enacted laws restricting or banning gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors. Most of those states face lawsuits. A federal judge struck down Arkansas’ ban as unconstitutional. In other states, judges have issued disparate rulings on whether the laws can be enforced while the cases are being litigated.
In Kentucky, U.S. District Judge David Hale had initially blocked Kentucky from enforcing the ban. But he lifted that injunction July 14, after the Sixth Circuit issued its ruling in the Tennessee case.
Seven transgender children and their parents have sued to block the Kentucky law. They argue that it violates their constitutional rights and interferes with parental rights to seek established medical treatment for their children.
In Monday’s ruling, judges Jeffrey Sutton, an appointee of former President George W. Bush, and Amul Thapar, an appointee of former President Donald Trump, said that the issues in the Kentucky case are essentially identical to those in Tennessee.
In the Tennessee case, the judges wrote that decisions on emerging policy issues like transgender care are generally better left to legislatures rather than judges. They offered a similar rationale Monday in the Kentucky case.
“The people of Kentucky enacted the ban through their legislature,” the judges wrote. “That body — not the officials who disagree with the ban — sets the Commonwealth’s policies.”
The dissenting judge, Helene White, noted that Kentucky’s ban does not include a grace period for patients who are already receiving care to continue treatment, as Tennessee’s law did.
As a result, White said the need for an injunction blocking the ban in Kentucky is even greater than it was in Tennessee.
“It seems obvious that there is a tremendous difference between a statute like Tennessee’s that allows flexibility regarding treatment decisions and time to explore alternatives and one like Kentucky’s that forces doctors to either discontinue treatment immediately or risk losing their license,” wrote White, who was first nominated by former President Bill Clinton and later nominated by Bush.
veryGood! (77)
Related
- Record-setting dry conditions threaten more US wildfires, drinking water supplies
- Gary Payton out as head coach at little-known California college
- Supreme Court will consider when doctors can provide emergency abortions in states with bans
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Build-A-Bear
- Candidates line up for special elections to replace Virginia senators recently elected to US House
- Former Wisconsin college chancellor fired over porn career is fighting to keep his faculty post
- Ashley Judd says late mom Naomi Judd's mental illness 'stole from our family'
- Migrants indicted in Texas over alleged border breach after judge dismissed charges
- Why Josh O'Connor Calls Sex Scenes Least Sexy Thing After Challengers With Zendaya and Mike Faist
- NBA playoffs Tuesday: Timberwolves take 2-0 lead on Suns; Pacers even series with Bucks
Ranking
- Disney Store's Black Friday Sale Just Started: Save an Extra 20% When You Shop Early
- 'Them: The Scare': Release date, where to watch new episodes of horror anthology series
- Tennessee legislature passes bill allowing teachers to carry concealed guns
- Ex-minor league umpire sues MLB, says he was harassed by female ump, fired for being bisexual man
- DWTS' Gleb Savchenko Shares Why He Ended Brooks Nader Romance Through Text Message
- New Jersey is motivating telecommuters to appeal their New York tax bills. Connecticut may be next
- Kim Kardashian Shares Photo With Karlie Kloss After Taylor Swift’s Tortured Poets Album Release
- Every Mom Wants Lululemon for Their Mother’s Day Gift – Shop Align Leggings, New Parent Bags & More
Recommendation
-
FanDuel Sports Network regional channels will be available as add-on subscription on Prime Video
-
74-year-old Ohio woman charged in armed robbery of credit union was scam victim, family says
-
Wisconsin prison inmate pleads not guilty to killing cellmate
-
Tennis' powerbrokers have big plans. Their ideas might not be good for the sport.
-
BITFII Introduce
-
74-year-old Ohio woman charged in armed robbery of credit union was scam victim, family says
-
More Than a Third of All Americans Live in Communities with ‘Hazardous’ Air, Lung Association Finds
-
Ex-officer wanted for 2 murders found dead in standoff, child found safe after Amber Alert